Thank goodness there is an actual product that works. My entire animal clan needed to be treated (3 cats 2 dogs) so I had my reservations. Well here it is 1 week later and my little dog no longer has “terrible” breath and I don’t see her defy my command to come on the grounds she found a pile of something else that was worth the time out she would be facing. After the forbid treatment and a bark collar for her excessive barking, I’m pretty sure she believes all the fun has been sucked out of being a little She-poo dog, especially since we got her at 2 years old. I’m pretty sure since she had 2 years for the habit to set in, both bad habits fall under the guidelines of “Old dog-new tricks”Little Dogs rock!!